I passed the checkride, now need a good GPS and passenger headset
Question:
Vincent, But some things, such as the average private pilot’s pilotage skills, certainly were. How about they were just different? I think a pilot who is not able to work the Garmin 430 in his airplane is lacking skills. But it’s a different set of skills than the one needed to work the ADF.
My point is that a new private pilot who does not have an IFR rating does not need an ADF, either! He needs to learn basic skills. He will not learn them if he can crank a destination into a GPS and fly there as is led by the hand. I think he’ll get a lot more pleasure, satisfaction, and a sense of accomplishment from finding his destination without the help of gadgets (unless you consider a compass and a chart as "gadgets"). And he’ll be a safer pilot, less likely to have to make a forced landing after his GPS fails and he runs out of fuel trying to figure out where he is. And if you think it’s reasonable to say a pilot is lacking skills if he can’t operate a Garmin 430, then I’ll suggest you’re incompetent because you can’t do celestial navigation. vince norris
Response:
Robert, Someone who does NOT know where they are without their GPS
Nobody ever doubted that. — Thomas Borchert (EDDH)
Response:
Vincent, But some things, such as the average private pilot’s pilotage skills, certainly were. How about they were just different? I think a pilot who is not able to work the Garmin 430 in his airplane is lacking skills. But it’s a different set of skills than the one needed to work the ADF. My point is that a new private pilot who does not have an IFR rating does not need an ADF, either! He needs to learn basic skills.
Good luck convincing anyone of that….
Response:
Absolutely. Someone who does NOT know where they are without their GPS is one electrical problem (or electronic failure) away from having no positional awareness. The plane I fly most times has a VFR GPS, which occasionally works, and when it does work, I have it on. When it doesn’t work I still make damn sure I know where I am by virtue of the sectional and when accurate distances are needed by the DME. No excuse for not knowing where you are. I doubt that "well my GPS failed" would work as an excuse in a certificate action for busting airspace. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Vincent, But some things, such as the average private pilot’s pilotage skills, certainly were. How about they were just different? I think a pilot who is not able to work the Garmin 430 in his airplane is lacking skills. But it’s a different set of skills than the one needed to work the ADF. My point is that a new private pilot who does not have an IFR rating does not need an ADF, either! He needs to learn basic skills. He will not learn them if he can crank a destination into a GPS and fly there as is led by the hand. I think he’ll get a lot more pleasure, satisfaction, and a sense of accomplishment from finding his destination without the help of gadgets (unless you consider a compass and a chart as "gadgets"). And he’ll be a safer pilot, less likely to have to make a forced landing after his GPS fails and he runs out of fuel trying to figure out where he is. And if you think it’s reasonable to say a pilot is lacking skills if he can’t operate a Garmin 430, then I’ll suggest you’re incompetent because you can’t do celestial navigation. vince norris
Response:
Please explain why it’s irresponsible. Well, I think I gave the reason. Remember the two bozos flying over Washington, DC and how much they hurt all of us?
They did that because they were incompetent, not because they didn’t have a GPS. I’ve flown for half a century in the Middle Atlantic states, which are full of various kinds of special use airpspace, and managed to stay out of trouble. So have thousands –perhaps tens of thousands — of other pilots. Simple map reading skills would have kept those "bozos" out of trouble. The had only to stay on the correct side of a sizeable river; they failed to do it. If they coulnd’t read a sectional, why do you suppose they could have read a GPS screen? Airliners have other RNAV equipment.
I asked a retired American Airlines 747 captain about this at lunch today. He said that until 1990 or ‘95, the planes he flew had only "basic" instruments; inferior to the equipment in many private aircraft. The poster said he NEEDED a GPS. That suggests dependency. Not to me.
Well, I’m "depending" on the definition of the word in the dictionary. I don’t know. Sounds a lot like the "When I was young, x was better" fallacy.
Some things were, some things were not. The old Adcock ranges were not better than VORs; ADF approaches (as we then called them) were not better than the ILS. But some things, such as the average private pilot’s pilotage skills, certainly were. They had little or nothing else to get them to their destination. vince norris
Response:
Vincent, But some things, such as the average private pilot’s pilotage skills, certainly were.
How about they were just different? I think a pilot who is not able to work the Garmin 430 in his airplane is lacking skills. But it’s a different set of skills than the one needed to work the ADF. — Thomas Borchert (EDDH)
Response:
Well, I think I gave the reason. Remember the two bozos flying over Washington, DC and how much they hurt all of us?
Let’s get this straight. The pilots didn’t "hurt" anybody. The feds hurt all of us, using those pilots as an excuse. Jose — The monkey turns the crank and thinks he’s making the music. for Email, make the obvious change in the address.
Response:
Well, let me take the opposite position: In today’s airspace, flying wihtout a GPS is IMHO irresponsible.
Please explain why it’s irresponsible. I understand that very few domestic airliners and commuters have GPS. Does every mililtary aircraft have GPS? Is it irressponsible to fly a J-3 NORDO, even into OSH? That "expensive" GPS is around 350 bucks or so.
The poster said, "I’m thinking of a higher end GPS, maybe even color." Having a GPS and not being able to navigate without it are two completely different things.
The poster said he NEEDED a GPS. That suggests dependency. And if you have been flying long, you know that a new pilot with a GPS will quickly become dependent and will never develop pilotage skills. It’s common knowledge that many recently trained pilots have not learned to navigate well. It’s often been discussed here. vince norris
Response:
Vincent, Please explain why it’s irresponsible. I understand that very few domestic airliners and commuters have GPS. Does every mililtary aircraft have GPS? Is it irressponsible to fly a J-3 NORDO, even into OSH?
Well, I think I gave the reason. Remember the two bozos flying over Washington, DC and how much they hurt all of us? Airliners have other RNAV equipment. The military too. Do I think a NORDO J-3 should have a handheld GPS? Yes, I’d strongly recommend it. The poster said he NEEDED a GPS. That suggests dependency.
Not to me. It’s common knowledge that many recently trained pilots have not learned to navigate well. It’s often been discussed here.
I don’t know. Sounds a lot like the "When I was young, x was better" fallacy. — Thomas Borchert (EDDH)
Response:
I see what happened
)) I cleared out OE of messages over a week old and your reply o Osbourne came up as the first message in a thread. I missed the (re;) Anyway, congratulations on your 300 hours!
))))) Dudley – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday. Congratulations Jeff. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought it"d be, and it went very well. I seem to remember saying this to myself after the first time I had sex!!!
) Dudley Henriques While I appreciate the sentiments Dudley, I’ve had my ticket for a bit now and will hit 300 hours in the next flight or two. Congratulations on the sex though. — Jeff ‘The Wizard of Draws’ Bucchino Cartoons with a Touch of Magic http://www.wizardofdraws.com More Cartoons with a Touch of Magic http://www.cartoonclipart.com
Response:
Vincent, No, Joe, you do not "need" a GPS. Well, let me take the opposite position: In today’s airspace, flying wihtout a GPS is IMHO irresponsible. There simply doesn’t need to be any connection between card reading abilities and having a GPS – unless you are an irresponsible pilot to start with.
I’m not sure I go along with the irresponsible part, but I certainly agree with the benefits of the GPS. For the same reason I tap danced on the desks (figuratively) of our local school administration 30 years ago to make sure computer litereacy reached our school’s curriculum. The basic concepts are unarguably absolute essentials. Once an aviator has those, then bring on the technology. Just today, my Lowrance 2000C let me turn around the southwest corner of R-2505 and shave six to ten miles off what used to be the "safe margin" to avoid the restricted area. There ain’t no line painted on the ground to show you where the boundaries are. Go Fly!! Casey
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday. Congratulations Jeff. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought it"d be, and it went very well. I seem to remember saying this to myself after the first time I had sex!!!
) Dudley Henriques
While I appreciate the sentiments Dudley, I’ve had my ticket for a bit now and will hit 300 hours in the next flight or two. Congratulations on the sex though. — Jeff ‘The Wizard of Draws’ Bucchino Cartoons with a Touch of Magic http://www.wizardofdraws.com More Cartoons with a Touch of Magic http://www.cartoonclipart.com
Response:
Vincent, No, Joe, you do not "need" a GPS.
Well, let me take the opposite position: In today’s airspace, flying wihtout a GPS is IMHO irresponsible. There simply doesn’t need to be any connection between card reading abilities and having a GPS – unless you are an irresponsible pilot to start with. so that you can find your way on the day that expensive GPS
That "expensive" GPS is around 350 bucks or so. And yes, something can always crap out. The GPS, the VOR, the chart, when it flies out the window. So what? If you can’t navigate with depending on a GPS, you’re an aeronautical cripple.
Having a GPS and not being able to navigate without it are two completely different things. — Thomas Borchert (EDDH) MessageEnd: ;-;
Response:
YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought I’d be, and went very well. Now I need an aviation GPS and ‘Guest Headset’, and I’m hoping that readers of this list will have recommendations about what to get, and where to buy it. Yes, I’ve seen the eBay auctions, and I’m thinking of a higher end GPS, maybe even color. Any suggestions or experiences with specific models and vendors will greatly help! Regards, Joe.
Response:
I got a Garmin 295, which is now discontinued. You might be able to get one cheap. It’s a little slow, but it is an excellent piece of equipment. I use it in a Sundowner, and I’ve never had to use an external antenna. I’ve had very little trouble with satellite reception. It’s an absolute lifesaver. I would guess the 296 is even better, faster and with terrain and obstructions. Les
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought I’d be, and went very well. Now I need an aviation GPS and ‘Guest Headset’, and I’m hoping that readers of this list will have recommendations about what to get, and where to buy it. Yes, I’ve seen the eBay auctions, and I’m thinking of a higher end GPS, maybe even color. Any suggestions or experiences with specific models and vendors will greatly help! Regards, Joe.
Response:
Now I need an aviation GPS and ‘Guest Headset’, and I’m hoping that readers of this list will have recommendations about what to get, and where to buy it. Yes, I’ve seen the eBay auctions, and I’m thinking of a higher end GPS, maybe even color.
Well, I have a Garmin GPSMAP 195 (with original packaging, PC cable, yoke mount, etc.) that I am willing to sell for a reasonable price. If you are thinking of springing for a color unit, and are computer savvy, I would suggest looking into a product like AnywhereMap in combination with the Garmin GPS10. The system will probably set you back $1100 or so, but it offers you future capabilities (such as the ability to add weather uplink, solid state AI, etc.) that a Garmin or Lowrance handheld does not offer. JKG
Response:
I’ve been a big Garmin fan until I tried out the Lowrance GPS (great unit and they include everything you need with the unit (unlike garmin, where everything is an optional accessory – like an external antenna RIGHT!). As for your passenger headset. You can find some great deals on the lightspeed website (they sell some of their refurbed units that have been turned in by pilots taking advantage of their ‘trade-up’ program. Congratulations! — — =—– Good Flights! Cecil PP-ASEL-IA Student – CP-ASEL Check out my personal flying adventures from my first flight to the checkride AND the continuing adventures beyond! Complete with pictures and text at: www.bayareapilot.com "I fly because it releases my mind from the tyranny of petty things." – Antoine de Saint-Exupery – "We who fly, do so for the love of flying. We are alive in the air with this miracle that lies in our hands and beneath our feet" – Cecil Day Lewis –
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought I’d be, and went very well. Now I need an aviation GPS and ‘Guest Headset’, and I’m hoping that readers of this list will have recommendations about what to get, and where to buy it. Yes, I’ve seen the eBay auctions, and I’m thinking of a higher end GPS, maybe even color. Any suggestions or experiences with specific models and vendors will greatly help! Regards, Joe.
Response:
Get a Garmin GPS 196. It’s WAAS capable and often has an accuracy of less than 9 ft with WASS enabled. As an IFR flyer I found the panel page an important backup in case I lose all my onboard instruments.
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought I’d be, and went very well. Now I need an aviation GPS and ‘Guest Headset’, and I’m hoping that readers of this list will have recommendations about what to get, and where to buy it. Yes, I’ve seen the eBay auctions, and I’m thinking of a higher end GPS, maybe even color. Any suggestions or experiences with specific models and vendors will greatly help! Regards, Joe.
The Lowrance 2000c meets with my approval most wholeheartedly. The color-coded terrain awareness feature is very comforting. — Jeff "The Wizard of Draws" Bucchino Cartoons with a Touch of Magic www.wizardofdraws.com www.cartoonclipart.com Lowrance 2000C is very good.
Response:
It’s only a month until Oshkosh. If you can go, that is the best place in the world to look at alternatives. Don’t overlook the option of a tablet PC that serves both in flight and as your regular PC. I bought an HP TC1100 and rationalized it that way. I am now thinking, though, I should have bought a Motion as the HP screen is more difficult to read in glare/sunlight conditions. eBay is the place for guest headsets. I have a low-end Telex that I bought in a package of pilot gear. Sold off what I didn’t want and got about what I paid for the package. Ended up with a "free" headset and some other stuff. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought I’d be, and went very well. Now I need an aviation GPS and ‘Guest Headset’, and I’m hoping that readers of this list will have recommendations about what to get, and where to buy it. Yes, I’ve seen the eBay auctions, and I’m thinking of a higher end GPS, maybe even color. Any suggestions or experiences with specific models and vendors will greatly help! Regards, Joe.
Response:
What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought it"d be, and it went very well. I seem to remember saying this to myself after the first time I had sex!!!
) Dudley Henriques
You’ve had sex? Sorry, couldn’t help myself. <G — Mortimer Schnerd, RN
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought it"d be, and it went very well. I seem to remember saying this to myself after the first time I had sex!!!
) Dudley Henriques You’ve had sex? Sorry, couldn’t help myself. <G
Had to sit on a special cushion for a week afterwards – poor chap.
Response:
("Mortimer Schnerd, RN" wrote) You’ve had sex?
Nothing unusual about that, except (years later), him using a GI-Joe and a Barbie doll, attached to long sticks, to reenact the encounter. Montblack :-)
Response:
YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! Now I need an aviation GPS ….
No, Joe, you do not "need" a GPS. At the risk of sounding like an old curmudgeon, let me suggest that what you now have is permission to practice flying. What you REALLY need is a great deal of practice reading an aeronautical chart so that you can find your way on the day that expensive GPS you want to buy craps out and you’re up there all alone with no idea where the hell you are. (And you’re about to blunder into a area where the F-16s will come looking for you.) If you can’t navigate with depending on a GPS, you’re an aeronautical cripple. vince norris
Response:
YIPPEE! I’m now a private pilot! I took and passed, the private pilot checkride on Tuesday.
Congratulations Jeff. What a relief! It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought it"d be, and it went very well.
I seem to remember saying this to myself after the first time I had sex!!!
) Dudley Henriques